Pokélemental!! in Suggest A Pokémon Forum

RSS
Email

0 Points

<< Previous Topic Next Topic >>

Pokélemental!!

Author

Comment

Rahjet

[-]

Suggestions Board Regular

Posts: 1032

May 2 10 2:52 PM

Wait, so there are four possible beginnings and 6? possible evolutions?

Current Suggestions:

Spikrist-->Krestile-->Sovereign

Ungrie-->Starven-->Gluddin

Clawtch-->Graspisces-->Neptalon (Comm. Works)

PF RPG Team:

1.Virrgoose (Neo)

LV: 14 ♂

-Tacke

-Leer

-Quick Attack

-Charm

-Copycat

2.Kolibrisk (Icarus)

LV: 14 ♂

-Peck

-Thundershock

-Supersonic

-Quick Attack

-Charge

Advertisement
	Remove this ad

bcnnm

[-]

Registered User

Posts: 4

May 2 10 2:52 PM

hi i iz malonkey1's little bro!

If you like Douglas Adams, post this in your sig!

Last Edited By: bcnnm May 2 10 3:27 PM. Edited 1 times.

Jolly

[-]

Suggestions Board Regular

Posts: 260

May 2 10 3:54 PM

Yes there is 6 xD

And thanks malonkey1

Glad to help anytime again.

SoR

[-]

Suggestions Board Regular

Posts: 299

May 2 10 5:45 PM

Okay, so even with 6 possible evolutions, that ends up being 10 pretty different pokemon you are suggesting here. I think it would be crazy to have two pokemon that are the same species, one is water/fire and one is wind/ground, with completely different abilities and movelists (or sort of different movelists if only some levels have different moves for different forms). That ends up being a bit ridiculous.

FoxOfWar

[-]

Suggestions Board Regular

Posts: 432

May 3 10 12:13 AM

I agree with SoR, this could easily get out of hand and slip into a sea of ridiculousness.

When life gives you lemons, you steal the sugar and put it on salt shakers.

Right?

Drufle

[-]

Pokémon Factory Worker

Suggestions Board Regular

Posts: 1276

May 3 10 12:04 PM

Right now, this seems much too complicated. A better idea might be to have a single base Pokemon, then have it evolve into the four elemental ones.

My GPX+ profile
http://gpxplus.net/user/Drufle

Userbar courtesy of ElementalPenguin
Dragon :)

PielordDx

[-]

Suggestions Board Regular

Posts: 1437

May 3 10 8:41 PM

*AhemEveeAhem*
Drufle's idea sounds more, controlled.

JDLJDL

[-]

Suggestions Board Regular

Posts: 3232

May 4 10 12:59 AM

This is quite, ah, different. The forms are all very different from one another...

Sign by Danasoft - Get Your Free Sign

Give me Internets!

malonkey1

[-]

Suggestions Board Regular

Posts: 124

May 4 10 1:21 PM

FoxOfWar wrote:
So, um, how's the element-changing work between forms? What changes it around? Also the forms are rather generic, I think we have enough "ball with eyes" suggestions already(heaven knows I'm sick and tired of seeing them). Help yourself in getting this approved, base them on *something* other than just "element balls" because they are not very interesting(and we have Castform already). Take a long stroll into the animal sections of Wikipedia, that should help.

Also, when it evolves it's possible to become a plethora of combinations(Wind becomes Wind/Water, Wind/Ground or Wind/Fire - and same for other elements)... seems an awful lot of type combinations in one line if that is indeed the case. Not sure if that would work...

At the bottom line, as negative as my post may seem, remember that I'm not part of the staff and you can safely just ignore my opinion if you don't like it

Yeah... this post was the reason that I changed the appearances of the various forms. I guess I came up with something too complex for everyone to really wrap their brains around... I can change the appearances of the various forms. If you guys want, I can edit it back. Plus, I still haven't been able to figure a moveset. Any help there?

EDIT: Made up a moveset... decent, n'est-ce pa?

Last Edited By: malonkey1 May 4 10 2:58 PM. Edited 1 times.

Advertisement
	Remove this ad

Therislash

[-]

Suggestions Board Regular

Posts: 372

May 4 10 2:14 PM

I think the best thing for all of us is some pictures. I'll work on some.

SoR

[-]

Suggestions Board Regular

Posts: 299

May 4 10 3:22 PM

Once again, I understand the different forms. My problem that we are calling four pokemon with different moves, appearences, abilities, and evolutions the same thing. The only similarity is the name and the egg. The moveset illustrates that they really are 4 different pokemon. They have 6 moves in common, which is not that many. Regarding the movelist, looking past my criticism, most pokemon don't learn all moves of their own type, even elemental ones. You need to put in some moves of different types. Also, adding in 4 new moves, especially moves that powerful, is pushing it a little.

Therislash

[-]

Suggestions Board Regular

Posts: 372

May 5 10 1:18 PM

Then I won't make a picture.

@Malonkey: What would the preferred movesets be for each one? I would have the last three elemental moves it learns and diffusion. There is absolutely NO diversity in the movelist. You might want to work on that

AlexFantastico

[-]

Suggestions Board Regular

Posts: 786

May 7 10 3:50 AM

Wow, this idea seems to be getting bashed a lot, but I really don't see what's so bad about it?
On the contrary to the critisms, it seems to me that having all the type variants as the same pokemon is the only way this idea could work! If they were all seperate Pokemon, THEN this idea would become ridiculous.

SoR

[-]

Suggestions Board Regular

Posts: 299

May 7 10 6:20 AM

Okay, but actually, since the PF rules state you can't have two different pokemon evolve into one, there would HAVE to be three evolutions for each of the original ones, meaning that this idea ends up suggesting 16 different pokemon. Thats more than eevee!

Okay, now that I have outlined my complaint against the idea, I'll only post positive things in this thread.

@Malonkey: The first sentence of the first dex is good, but the rest of the dexes are a little bit off. They sound a bit more like descriptions, but it is much better if you share interesting tidbits. Some things to think about are: How does the egg know what the environment is? How do two different elemental forms interact? How does it feel about big cities? etc.

ZeldaFan

[-]

Suggestions Board Regular

Posts: 922

May 7 10 8:10 AM

Although it would be okay if they're the same pokemon in different forms, but that doesn't really make sense anyway. Like if Shellos evolved into different Gastrodon forms based on which coast you were on. I think that if you really want different forms make there a way to change between them, otherwise they're really just different pokemon with the same name and similar movelists. They don't even have the same Ht/Wt!

Follow Superbeedrill to my party!
--->

<---

82% of Pokemon Factory users think Dialga is better
than Palkia. If you are part of the 18% of users who
know Palkia is better than Dialga, please copy-paste
this to your signature.

<My birthday. Zigzagoon. Wait...What's this?

AlexFantastico

[-]

Suggestions Board Regular

Posts: 786

May 7 10 8:45 AM

SoR, there are only two Pokemon in this suggestion? The first one that can be one of 4 types, which then evolves to gain an extra type, up to 6 different combinations. But the first and second forms are just one Pokemon each.

There's nothing wrong with the forms being permanent either, we see the exact same thing on Wormadam.

Rahjet

[-]

Suggestions Board Regular

Posts: 1032

May 7 10 1:07 PM

Not to this extreme, so I do not think it is the same case. I believe that point was refuted earlier.

Current Suggestions:

Spikrist-->Krestile-->Sovereign

Ungrie-->Starven-->Gluddin

Clawtch-->Graspisces-->Neptalon (Comm. Works)

PF RPG Team:

1.Virrgoose (Neo)

LV: 14 ♂

-Tacke

-Leer

-Quick Attack

-Charm

-Copycat

2.Kolibrisk (Icarus)

LV: 14 ♂

-Peck

-Thundershock

-Supersonic

-Quick Attack

-Charge

AlexFantastico

[-]

Suggestions Board Regular

Posts: 786

May 8 10 1:09 AM

Well I suppose it's for the Staff to decide whether it's workable or not, when it comes time to review.

<< Previous Topic Next Topic >>

Yuku free message boards

Pokélemental!!